ESG Reporting Improves for Leveraged Finance Firms

Published on:
by KnowESG
KnowESG_ESG reporting
Image courtesy of https://www.chooose.today/

9fin, the leading platform for intelligence on the leveraged finance (LevFin) markets, has released its analysis of the state of ESG reporting, revealing differences across countries, private/public companies, and significant gaps in standardised data relating to social factors.

Highlights from the report:

  • Gender pay gap and board ethnic diversity are the least reported ESG metrics: Just 10% of LevFin companies report on these factors.

  • Private companies lag on ESG disclosure: Companies report on average just 41% of standardised metrics as part of 9fin's ESG Company Data.

  • Disclosure rate and emissions performance are not correlated with debt burden, despite the theory that a higher debt burden will negatively affect ESG performance.

  • Between 2020 and 2021, total scope 1 emissions across our sample decreased by 4%. Likewise, on average, emissions intensity decreased by 4%. This finding is at odds with the IEA, which found global CO2 emissions rose 6% between 2020 and 2020.

  • We cannot be confident that high yield companies are actually reducing emissions. 9fin has found instances where companies are incorrectly recording/re-calculating YoY emissions.

  • Nordic companies disclose almost twice as much data as laggard nations. Of the 11 possible data points, Swedish companies lead, reporting an average of 6.15. Followed by Norway (5.4), Greece (5.1), Belgium (5.1), and the UK (5). In contrast, the laggards in Spain, France, and Ireland reported just 3.8, 3.6, and 3.5 standardised metrics, respectively.

The analysis also looked at whether ESG disclosures are guiding asset allocation. 9fin analysed 430 ESG funds containing HY names to see if the top holdings' names performed well in sustainability.

In general, the top holdings:

  • demonstrate higher than average disclosure;

  • are likely to have issued sustainability-linked debt; and

  • have validated SBTi targets.

However, several companies have been flagged in 9fin's proprietary analysis as ESG laggards. Examples include companies that have had recent and material UNGC/OECD violations, which are common but have not always upheld the requirements of many ESG funds.

9fin offers 14 standardised metrics as part of its ESG Company Data offering, which enables clients to comply with the Sustainable Financial Disclosure Regulation's (SFDR) Principle Adverse Impact (PAI). With 4.5 standardised points disclosed on average per company out of a possible 11 (excluding 3 SBTi data points), EU fund managers will struggle to report against these metrics.

"Although we see an improvement in ESG reporting within LevFin, our analysis shows some major gaps and inconsistencies. You have to question whether investors can consistently rely on this data to inform investment decisions and meet EU regulatory requirements," said Jack David, Head of ESG, 9fin.

To view and compare company ESG Ratings and Sustainability Reports across sectors, follow our Company ESG Profiles page.

For more regulatory news

Source: PRNewswire

Share:
esg
esg
esg
esg

Regulators Headlines

Closing the Climate Gap: How the SBTi Revision Impacts Corporate Net-Zero Plans

Closing the Climate Gap: How the SBTi Revision Impacts Corporate Net-Zero Plans

Trump Backs 24 States Suing New York and Vermont Over Climate Liability Laws

Trump Backs 24 States Suing New York and Vermont Over Climate Liability Laws

Businesses Call for UK–EU Carbon Market Connection

EU to Expressly Set Out Sustainability Reporting Rules by October

Trump’s Support for Seabed Mining Draws EU Criticism

EU Moots Plans to Ban Carbon Fibre by 2029

PwC: Singapore's Sustainability Legal Services to Triple by 2033

SBTi Releases Revised Corporate Net-Zero Standards for Public Input

Research: European ESG Funds Invested Over €123B in Fossil Fuels

Australian Super Fund Active Super Fined $10.5M Over Greenwashing